Who's behind the board
Why this
exists
Prop markets are the softest thing on a sportsbook's menu and the worst-served corner of the pick-selling business. The gap between those two facts is the whole company.
The short version
Sports Prop Madness is run by Joseph Tuttle, who has spent years building projection models and handicapping tools across football, baseball, basketball, and harness racing — including Totals Only, TigerPicks, and ScorePredictor. Same modeling desk, same refusal to sell a parlay as a lock, aimed at player props.
Why props
Sportsbooks put their best pricing on sides and totals, because that's where the volume and the sharp money live. Player props are priced faster, updated later, and shaded harder toward whatever the public wants to bet. That means more mistakes on the board — and more mistakes means more edges for anyone actually building numbers instead of reading a hot-take account.
The catch is that props are a lot of work. There are hundreds of them a night across five books, and the edges are small enough that finding them by hand isn't realistic. That's what the seeding system is for: it does the sorting so you're looking at the ten props worth your money instead of the two hundred that aren't.
What we're not
- Not a sportsbook. We don't accept wagers or hold anyone's betting money.
- Not a lock service. Nobody here has ever been 12-0. The people telling you they were are showing you a screenshot from a group where they also sent the other side.
- Not a hype account. No countdown timers, no “last chance,” no fake urgency. The board drops at 9am whether you're in or not.
The standard we hold ourselves to
Every pick is timestamped when it posts. Every pick grades automatically. The full history stays public, losing stretches included — and until there is a graded history, we post nothing at all. If we ever quietly clean up a record, the whole thing is worthless — so we built it to make that impossible rather than promising not to.
Contact
Best way to reach us is Discord, where the modeling desk actually hangs out. Otherwise:
- Discord — open to all paid members, invite comes with access
- YouTube — slate breakdowns and the monthly film session
- Payments — Cash App at $TuttlemathWinsGames, and nowhere else
Fill out your bracket.
A free 1-seed drops every morning at 9am ET. No card to look, no calls, no “DM me for the play.”